
[Video]
[3.00]
[6]
Wayne Weizhen Zhang: Genuinely Googled if Haven was an AI artist after my first listen, before (mercifully) finding the artists Insta. The nicest thing I have to say about “I Run” is that Kaitlin Aragon sounds extremely dedicated to the conceit of drowning and sounding out of breath.
[1]
Al Varela: Would have been a big fat [0] if they kept the AI vocals. It’s bad enough that streaming services allow AI songs to be slipped into their algorithm for unsuspecting people using autoplay, we don’t need actual viral hits to be enabling this bullshit further. Now that they did get a real vocalist for the song though, we’re just left with a song that wasn’t even good to begin with. A nothing snippet built to play in the background of TikTok slop for your eyes to glaze over and your ears to tune out hearing the same song on every video over and over again. No thanks.
[1]
Iain Mew: Rerecording songs with a soundalike because a sample couldn’t be cleared is an age-old practice — “Gym and Tonic”/”Gymtonic” in 1998 comes to mind. Usually, as then, it’s for the worse. This isn’t a case of an uncleared sample, though, but something rather different. The original AI-powered version of “I Run” is tough to even find, but based on some snippets, Kaitlin Aragon has done an impressive job. Her vocal sounds exactly like an incoherent averaged-out set of signifiers.
[3]
Nortey Dowuona: The first knee jerk reaction was fear. The second was panic. The final one was sadness. But then came anger.
[4]
Scott Mildenhall: Don’t back down, double down. You could go in for half measures about “just embracing that it does sound like her”, or you could just hype the machine further. Say the robots made you do it! That you had no choice but to channel their reconstituted beats into Jorjan architecture. Because really, did you push the button, or did the button push you? If you don’t need quality control, you might not need any control.
[4]
Will Adams: Top of the Slops.
[2]
I love coming into these blog posts with zero context for what I’m about to experience and getting to wonder just what the hell all the strong reactions are about XD in this case, it does seem to be warranted
not worse than anything Marshmello ever did [4]
I would love to know what this song would have sounded like to me without the context, since I only first heard about it from it being banned from the chart. Although for whatever it’s worth it clearly was already popular and isn’t only getting attention because of its issues.